Iiyama PLE431S, Hyundai Q17 or Sony SDM HX73S - which one ?

  • Hi
    I want to buy 17" LCD.
    - Iiyama PLE431S
    - Hyundai Q17
    - Sony HX73S


    I saw PLE431S & Q17 in a market - they have good picture quality and don't blurring in a games.
    Last LCD - Sony HX73S is a riddle for me.
    I read post of HX73S' user on HardOCP forum.
    He wrote that Sony HX73S is best LCD ever had:



    Another man wrote that Sony use LCD panels manufactured by Sony with response time 16ms and it's TRUE 24bit color panel- displays 16 700 000 colors - , not an 18 bit like 16ms panel from AU Optronics who displays only 262 000 colors:



    Generally :
    Iiyama offers best warranty - on 1 dead pixel
    Hyundai is probably best LCD today - winner Tomshardware's test - Hyundai's warranty is worse but ratio power to price is best.
    Sony has great design but I don't know how is picture quality :-/


    Please help me choose best form this list :)
    I'll be very thankful.


    P.S.
    If you could please answer in english ;)

  • Try to buy the Hyundai ImageQuest Q17 with digital in. Thats the panel with the best technicial datas and the service from Hyundai ist in germany very quick. I can´t understood why the warranty from hyundai is so worse?


    If there is an dead pixel in the middle of the LCD, they would change this one. And otherwise you could buy in our shop one LCD without any dead pixels. We offer a model that is tested and without a dead pixel.


    www.mfe-pc.de


    With best reguards
    M. Fleischer

  • yeah thx 4 advice :)
    I bought Hyundai Q17 (DVI&D-sub) :)
    But in specification on pdf from cd with drivers Hyunday says that this monitor has 25ms response time. In every specification on the websites write that Hyundai has 20 ms response time (HyDis panel) - what the hell is going on?
    Please tell me what are the best settings for that LCD?

  • On the backside of monitor:
    Model: Q17
    Type No.: L17C0D081
    FCC ID: PJIL17C0D081
    Serial No.: Q170SAS937916264
    Manufactured: July 2003
    P/N : 631 6332 927
    Rev.00


    On the BOX:
    EAN: 8809093741041
    S/N: Q170SAS937916264
    F/G Code: LMQ17AUS0BES51-HIE-01


    Is it exactly the same Hyundai Q17 like in tomshardware's test with 20ms HyDis Panel ?